Eggnog is the quintessential Christmas drink, offering a rich and creamy indulgence that feels like holiday cheer in a glass. While the classic recipe is a go-to for many, there are plenty of creative variations to suit every palate. Here’s a guide to different ways to make eggnog and one fantastic place to find it if you’d rather sip than stir.
Classic Eggnog Recipe
The traditional eggnog recipe starts with fresh eggs, whole milk, cream, sugar, nutmeg, and a splash of your favorite spirit—brandy, rum, or bourbon. Whisk the eggs and sugar until creamy, gradually add the milk and cream, and spike it to taste. Heat the mixture lightly for a cooked version or keep it raw with pasteurized eggs for convenience. See Recipe
Dairy-Free and Vegan Eggnog
For those avoiding dairy or animal products, vegan eggnog is a delicious alternative. Use almond milk, oat milk, or coconut milk as a base, and blend with cashews or silken tofu for a creamy texture. Sweeten with maple syrup or agave, and flavor with vanilla extract and nutmeg. A pinch of turmeric can give it a warm, golden hue reminiscent of traditional eggnog. See recipe
Spiced and Flavored Eggnog
Elevate your eggnog by experimenting with flavors. Add spices like cloves, cardamom, or cinnamon for a richer profile. For a festive twist, mix in caramel, chocolate syrup, or even coffee for a mocha-egg nog hybrid. You can also use spiced rum or hazelnut liqueur to complement the creamy base. See recipe
Eggnog Without Eggs
If you love the flavor but aren’t keen on using eggs, try a custard-inspired recipe with cornstarch or a pudding mix as a thickener. The result is a velvety drink that’s just as satisfying but egg-free. See recipe
Where to Find the Best Eggnog
If you prefer to leave the whisking to someone else, head to Trader Joe’s for one of the best selections of eggnog. They offer traditional, light, and even dairy-free varieties, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Their seasonal eggnog is rich, perfectly spiced, and ready to pour, making it an excellent choice for any holiday gathering.
Whether you make it yourself or pick up a bottle, eggnog is a delightful way to toast the holiday season. Try one of these variations or grab a cup from Trader Joe’s and enjoy the creamy comfort of this festive classic.
What’s your favorite way to enjoy eggnog? Share your thoughts in the comments!
